Prime Minister Andy Burnham has promised to take power away from Westminster and put it into the hands of local communities. English mayors are being offered greater control, Scotland already exercises powers Wales has long sought, yet a letter sent to First Minister Rhun ap Iorwerth on Friday (20 November) suggests that when it comes to Wales, Westminster remains  reluctant to let go.

“The biggest rebalancing of power our country has ever seen.” – Andy Burnham

That was the ambitious promise made by Prime Minister Andy Burnham as he outlined his vision for a new era of devolution across the United Kingdom.

His message was clear. Britain is too centralised. Too many decisions are made in Westminster by politicians and civil servants far removed from the communities affected by them.

Power, he argued, should be transferred away from Whitehall and placed in the hands of those who understand their local areas.

His government even adopted the principle of “devolution by default” – the idea that powers should be exercised locally unless there is a compelling reason for Westminster to retain them.

Fine words. Ambitious promises. A supposedly fundamental change in how Britain is governed.

But there appears to be one rather significant problem.

What happens when Wales asks for more powers?

In a letter dated 20 November 2026, the Prime Minister responded to First Minister Rhun ap Iorwerth’s calls for a new constitutional and financial settlement for Wales.

The Welsh Government had requested the transfer of significant responsibilities, including policing and justice, management of the Crown Estate and rail infrastructure.

Burnham’s response was he was “not persuaded” by the arguments for transferring these responsibilities to Wales.

On policing, the Prime Minister defended the existing England and Wales system, arguing that it enables cross-border cooperation and access to specialist resources.

On justice, he maintained that Wales benefits from the expertise and resources of a shared legal system.

On the Crown Estate, which includes valuable seabed rights around the Welsh coast, he argued that the existing arrangements offer the best opportunities for economic investment.

And on rail infrastructure, he said transferring responsibility to Wales could fragment the network, particularly given the importance of cross-border services.

The letter was not entirely negative. Burnham reaffirmed major investment commitments, including support for Wylfa, Port Talbot and Welsh rail projects, while leaving the door open to further discussions about employment support, financial flexibility and closer cooperation.

But on the central demands for additional Welsh powers, the answer was no.

A Prime Minister promising to take power away from Westminster had just explained why Westminster should retain power over Wales.

A spokesperson for Rhun ap Iorwerth accused Burnham of “turning his back on devolution”, describing the letter as deeply disappointing.

The Welsh Government acknowledged progress on fiscal flexibility and welcomed the prospect of further economic discussions, but made clear that these did not compensate for the refusal to transfer major responsibilities.

Its response went directly to the heart of Burnham’s wider devolution agenda:

“His warm words on devolution are now ringing hollow and there is no longer any doubt that when he talks of driving power out of Whitehall, he only means to the regions of England.”

The First Minister’s office also argued that refusing to explore the transfer of policing, justice, the Crown Estate and rail infrastructure demonstrated that the Prime Minister did not regard Wales as an equal nation within the United Kingdom.

The Welsh Government maintains that the current settlement denies Wales opportunities to benefit more directly from its natural resources, secure fairer rail investment and develop a justice system better suited to its needs.

These are serious accusations against a Prime Minister who has made decentralisation one of the defining themes of his government.

And they raise a question that cannot simply be dismissed as a disagreement between two political parties.

Power for English mayors, but not for Wales?

Burnham’s government has outlined plans to give English mayors greater control over taxation, transport, employment support, skills, planning and regional economic development.

Under the proposals, mayors would gain greater influence over how public money is raised and spent, with more decisions taken locally rather than dictated by Westminster.

The government has described its programme as a historic transfer of power, and there is a perfectly reasonable argument for doing so. Local leaders understand their communities, their economies and their transport networks better than ministers sitting hundreds of miles away.

But surely that same principle applies to Wales?

The Welsh Government is not a local council or a newly established mayoral authority. It is an established national government, accountable to a democratically elected Senedd, with responsibility for health, education, housing and numerous other public services. Yet when it asks for greater control over policing, justice, the Crown Estate and rail infrastructure, the response from Westminster is substantially different. Suddenly, the arguments for local decision-making appear to become less persuasive and retaining powers centrally is presented as the sensible option.

Scotland can do it. Why can’t Wales?

The contrast becomes even more difficult to explain when Scotland enters the picture. Scotland already controls its own policing arrangements, criminal justice system, courts and prisons. It also manages its Crown Estate assets and exercises substantial responsibility over railway infrastructure. These are not hypothetical powers but responsibilities that have been exercised within the United Kingdom for years, without Scotland having to leave the Union.

Wales, meanwhile, continues to seek comparable responsibilities that remain under Westminster’s control. The Crown Estate provides a particularly significant example, given the potential economic benefits of offshore renewable energy development around the Welsh coast.

Scotland has managed its Crown Estate assets since 2017, including valuable seabed rights associated with offshore energy development. Wales, despite its enormous renewable energy potential, does not enjoy the same arrangement. The Welsh Government has repeatedly argued that control over the Crown Estate would allow Wales to benefit more directly from its natural resources.

In his letter, Burnham maintains that the existing Crown Estate arrangements provide the best means of maximising economic and social benefits for Wales. The UK Government argues that the Crown Estate’s scale, financial capacity and specialist expertise support major investment projects, particularly in offshore wind.

However, the different arrangements in Scotland and Wales raise questions about why devolved management is considered appropriate in one nation but not the other, particularly when both have significant offshore energy resources.

The policing contradiction

Perhaps the most striking example concerns policing. Before becoming Prime Minister, Burnham served as Mayor of Greater Manchester, a position that carried significant responsibilities for policing oversight and accountability. His government’s wider devolution programme continues to support greater regional influence over policing arrangements in England.

Rhun ap Iorwerth has previously pointed out that Burnham enjoyed more influence over policing as Mayor of Greater Manchester than the First Minister of Wales currently possesses. Yet the UK Government has rejected the transfer of policing responsibilities to the Welsh Government, despite Scotland already operating its own devolved police service.

In his letter, Burnham argues that retaining an integrated England and Wales policing system supports cross-border cooperation, particularly in tackling serious and organised crime. He maintains that the current arrangements provide access to national specialist capabilities and that legislative devolution is not necessary to achieve improvements in policing.

There is an important distinction between the policing oversight exercised by English mayors and the full legislative responsibilities sought by the Welsh Government. However, the different approaches raise questions about why greater local democratic accountability is being promoted in England while the transfer of policing powers to Wales remains opposed.

Rather than agreeing to full devolution, Burnham has proposed exploring a stronger role for the Welsh Government in policing governance, potentially drawing on aspects of the English mayoral model. The Welsh Government, however, continues to argue that Wales should have responsibilities comparable to those already exercised in Scotland.

Welsh rail: another power Westminster won’t surrender

Rail infrastructure provides another example of the different devolution arrangements across Britain. The Welsh Government already has significant responsibilities for passenger rail services through Transport for Wales, but responsibility for most rail infrastructure in Wales remains with Westminster.

This creates a division of responsibilities in which the Welsh Government is expected to improve passenger services without having equivalent control over much of the infrastructure on which those services depend. Scotland, by comparison, has substantially greater responsibility for railway infrastructure funding and planning.

Burnham’s letter acknowledges the historic underfunding of Welsh rail and highlights substantial investment commitments, including a wider pipeline of projects valued at up to £14 billion. He also refers to plans for closer cooperation between Great British Railways, Transport for Wales and the Welsh Government, alongside a greater Welsh role in determining investment priorities.

However, the Prime Minister has rejected the transfer of rail infrastructure responsibilities to Wales, arguing that the cross-border nature of the network makes an integrated approach preferable. He maintains that devolving infrastructure could fragment the railway system and affect services connecting Wales and England.

The Welsh Government’s position is that greater control over infrastructure would allow it to plan and deliver improvements more effectively. The disagreement therefore concerns not only how much investment Wales receives, but also which government should make the decisions about how that investment is managed and delivered.

Even Welsh Labour wants more powers

The disagreement over devolution is not confined to the Plaid Cymru-led Welsh Government. Welsh Labour leader Ken Skates has also reaffirmed support for devolving policing and the Crown Estate to Wales, highlighting differences between the position of Welsh Labour and that of the Labour Prime Minister.

Speaking at the Welsh Labour conference in Llandudno earlier this month, Skates made clear that these commitments remained part of Welsh Labour’s policy position. This means Burnham is resisting the transfer of responsibilities that his own party’s leadership in Wales has publicly supported.

The contrasting positions also demonstrate that demands for greater Welsh devolution are not confined to Plaid Cymru or supporters of independence. They form part of a wider debate about whether Wales has sufficient powers and financial responsibilities to govern effectively within the United Kingdom.

Every postcode – but whose decisions?

Burnham has repeatedly spoken about spreading economic opportunity across Britain, promising good growth in every postcode. His government argues that investment, reindustrialisation and regional empowerment are essential to improving living standards and reducing geographical inequalities, particularly in communities affected by industrial decline.

The Prime Minister’s letter highlights several examples of investment intended to support economic growth in Wales, including nuclear energy at Wylfa, steel production at Port Talbot, rail infrastructure and renewable energy development. These commitments represent substantial investment, but they are separate from the question of whether Wales should exercise greater control over the decisions affecting its economy and public services.

A new factory, railway improvement or major investment announcement may bring significant economic benefits, but does not necessarily transfer decision-making authority away from Westminster. Equally, devolving additional powers would not automatically guarantee greater investment. The disagreement centres on how responsibilities should be divided between the UK and Welsh governments.

Burnham’s letter offers continued cooperation, discussions about employment support and fiscal flexibility, and a potentially stronger Welsh role in policing governance and justice arrangements. However, on several of the Welsh Government’s most substantial requests for additional powers, Westminster’s position remains unchanged.

Devolution by default – but questions remain over Wales

The UK Government’s wider devolution programme has been built around the principle of transferring more decision-making powers away from Westminster, with English mayors expected to receive greater responsibilities for transport, skills, economic development and local public services.

However, the Prime Minister’s letter of 20 November makes clear that the government does not intend to extend that approach to several of the principal powers requested by Wales. Burnham argues that retaining the existing arrangements for policing, justice, the Crown Estate and rail infrastructure offers practical advantages, including cross-border cooperation, access to specialist resources and greater certainty for investment.

The Welsh Government disputes that position, pointing to the powers already exercised in Scotland and arguing that Wales should have greater responsibility for decisions affecting its public services, infrastructure and natural resources.

The disagreement highlights the different approaches being taken to devolution within the United Kingdom. While the UK Government is proposing additional powers for English regional authorities, it is resisting the transfer of several national responsibilities to the Senedd. These are not directly equivalent forms of devolution, but they raise questions about how the government’s commitment to transferring power away from Westminster will apply across the four nations.

What happens next?

Despite the disagreements, Burnham’s letter confirms that discussions between the UK and Welsh governments will continue. The Prime Minister has proposed further work on employment support, justice arrangements, policing governance and fiscal flexibility, alongside continued cooperation on economic investment.

He also highlighted commitments to major projects in Wales, including Wylfa, Port Talbot and improvements to the railway network. However, there is currently no agreement to transfer responsibility for policing, the Crown Estate or rail infrastructure to the Welsh Government.

Rhun ap Iorwerth’s office has made clear its disappointment, accusing the Prime Minister of failing to match his wider ambitions for devolution with equivalent commitments to Wales.

The dispute leaves a significant constitutional question unresolved: how far will the UK Government’s promised rebalancing of power extend beyond England’s mayoral authorities?

For now, the Prime Minister’s letter establishes that several of the additional powers sought by Wales will remain at Westminster.

Photo: Official portrait of Andy Burnham, 2026.